News & Info

A Second Helping of Gratitude: How Data-Driven Direct Mail ReMail™ Campaigns Multiply Donor Impact

11/10/2025

As Thanksgiving approaches, our thoughts turn naturally to gratitude — for good food, good company, and the second helpings that make the holiday memorable. In fundraising, there’s another kind of “second helping” that deserves attention: the strategic direct mail follow-up known as ReMail™.

Just like Thanksgiving leftovers give us a chance to enjoy something meaningful again, a well-timed direct mail follow-up gives your first appeal a second chance to inspire action.

Making the Most of What’s Already Good

Even the strongest direct mail appeals can get lost in a busy season. People intend to give, but they forget. ReMail™ gives them another chance.

This second drop isn’t a repeat — it’s a data-informed re-engagement tactic. Using insights from the first mailing, VeraData helps nonprofits identify which supporters are most likely to respond to a reminder. The timing, creative treatment, and message are optimized for conversion while the emotional tone stays genuine.

A ReMail™ campaign, sent two to four weeks after the original drop, captures those who simply needed another moment — or another nudge — to give. It makes every dollar of your first campaign work harder.

Data Meets Gratitude: The Science Behind the Second Drop

VeraData’s Donor Science™ approach transforms traditional direct mail into a precision instrument. Our ReMail™ Model uses years of campaign performance data and advanced machine learning to predict which donors are most likely to respond to a second appeal. This means your follow-up mailings are targeted, cost-efficient, and grounded in real donor behavior — not guesswork.

It’s a data-driven expression of appreciation: we see you, we value you, and we’re giving you another opportunity to make a difference.

That thoughtful precision pays off. On average, second-drop mailings outperform initial appeals, turning “thank you for considering” into “thank you for giving.”

A Case Study in Second Chances

One VeraData nonprofit client in the education and social services sector faced declining acquisition response rates and turned to ReMail™ to re-energize their outreach. The results were transformative.

By letting data drive both timing and targeting, the client saw a 50% increase in response rate on their first drop and a 58% year-over-year boost on the ReMail™ second drop. Even more impressive: overall acquisition performance improved with 39% more new donors and a 58% increase in total revenue.

That’s the power of combining heartfelt appeals with analytical precision — a perfect recipe for success during the season of giving.

Serving Gratitude All Year Long

Gratitude shouldn’t end when the holiday does. The same principle applies to donor engagement. A well-timed, data-guided ReMail™ tells supporters: your gift still matters, and it’s never too late to make an impact.

It’s not just about sending another piece of mail — it’s about reinforcing connection, strengthening trust, and maximizing the return on every campaign investment.

Because when appreciation is followed by action, generosity multiplies.

Discover how VeraData’s data-driven ReMail™ strategy can help you re-engage donors, improve ROI, and extend the spirit of gratitude long after Thanksgiving.